The death‑penalty debate resurfaced in American politics after the botched execution in Tennessee and President Trump’s approval of the execution by firing squad of Army Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan for the 2009 shooting at Fort Hood, Texas. I do not support capital punishment; I believe it is wrong for the state to wield the power to kill people who have already taken lives. Allowing the government to use the very violence it condemns is a contradiction—violence does not produce justice.
I will leave the issue of Army Maj. Hasan for now, but I want to reflect on the botched execution of Christa Gail Pike, a 50‑year‑old woman who had been on death row since she was 18. When the lethal‑injection protocol failed twice, she was rushed to a hospital. I found it odd that Governor Bill Lee, who was asked to intervene, declined to halt the process; after the second failed attempt, however, he expressed remorse for what had occurred. Yet the prison system chief, Frank Strada, announced his resignation.
I keep asking myself what the rationale was: the state intended to kill her, failed, and then felt sorry that she survived. Why rush her to the hospital to save her life only to try to kill her again? Is this justice?
To me, this is one of the problems of the death penalty—we celebrate a “successful” execution only when it proceeds without a struggle. Like Ms. Pike, we seem to believe we have ultimate power to determine who lives and dies. We are wrong. What we witnessed is a soul refusing to go quietly, reminding us that only the Creator—not a governor or the courts—determines a person’s lifespan. It is disheartening that this religious dimension is often ignored, even though many of us invoke “the Lord’s will” in these debates.
I am not excusing the crime Ms. Pike committed at 18; it was grave and merited serious consequences. However, our justice system must recognize that people can change. She is now 50—a different person from the teenager who committed the offense. To treat her as the same individual ignores the reality of personal growth over time. Is it not logical to advocate for life imprisonment? What do we lose?
Moreover, why do those of us who claim to uphold biblical teachings struggle most with forgiveness? Why do states that claim to uphold Christian values feel entitled to determine who lives and dies? Our society needs to cultivate a culture that extends grace to those who have spent decades on death row. We do not become better by becoming like our enemies—that is what the death penalty teaches us. May we find the humility and compassion to heal, trusting that, in the end, judgment belongs to a higher power.
From the E-Crier of October 8, 2026. Subscribe to the weekly newsletter.